A Skeleton in the Closet


http://www.flickr.com/photos/danielle-chang/5048007241/By Abu Nusaybah

When said: “Muslims are terrorists”, we quickly point out the faulty logic in that statement. We know this is not true. We know this idea and statement have harmful impacts. As a result, we oppose it. The argument goes something like this:

A, B and C are Muslims.

A, B and C are Terrorists.

Therefore all Muslims are terrorists.

Without doubt not all Muslims are terrorists, and the fact that some terrorists identify as Muslims does not make all Muslims that way. The conclusion that all Muslims are terrorists is a logical fallacy, an error in thinking. The specific has been made general without evidence.

Although we are enthusiastic in responding to, correcting and criticizing the statement that “Muslims are terrorists”, we are guilty far too often of making the same errors when speaking about others. Take, for example:

A, B and C are [insert ethnic group].

A, B and C are [insert negative trait].

Therefore all [ethnic group] are [negative trait].

No specific examples of commonly held racial and ethnic stereotypes that negatively portray one people will be presented here. However, in the negative trait part of the above sentences you’ve probably heard it completed with:  are stupid, are bad drivers, are thieves, are violent, are liars, are dirty, are criminals, are poor, are lazy… the list goes on. We hear them. May Allah protect us, we may even say them. We may use names for certain groups in a demeaning fashion. Somehow, in these cases, we tend not to see the logical fallacy, the hatred and the discrimination.

Naturally, we are quick to point to the stance Islam takes against racism and discrimination. Standing shoulder to shoulder in prayer. The final sermon. That humans are created equal. Examples of racism being dealt with by the Prophet ﷺ (peace be upon him).

To a degree, stereotypes are a result of natural and normal thinking, not rooted in hatred. The complex world around us is made simpler with generalizations of this sort. These become problematic when laden with value and judgment. Often this “othering” is a product of lacking interaction with the group in question. In other cases, ideas might be influenced by the media or a limited set of experiences. Some may even defend these stereotypes by pointing to correlational or experiential evidence. However, the “Muslims are terrorists” case ought to be a telling reminder of how harmful these incorrect ideas can be. Furthermore, persistence of these ideas can result in prejudice, discrimination and hate, whereby jokes manifest themselves in destructive forms. These ideas may also negatively influence members of the discriminated group who may begin to think less of themselves and lower their standards, a self-fulfilling prophesy of sorts.

As the Companions struggled with this issue, it ought to come as no surprise that we too struggle with this issue. That struggle, in fact, is the only valid way in which we differ, that is through our piety. First and foremost we need to recognize and acknowledge that these stereotypes, generalizations and discriminatory ideas exist. Individually and collectively we need to stand for justice, by challenging our own prejudices and advising those from whom we hear such ideas. Racism, discrimination and hate will only be effectively dealt with when each of us, all of us, value and treat others equally. This challenge may not disappear, which means there will always be room for improvement, room for struggle and room for refinement.

Print Friendly

3 Comments

  1. Aryel Lanes says:

    That’s so sad! Really! I know what you mean… I think just like you, and I even made a video explaining that Muslims are no that bad!

    I’m from Brazil, and even here people have misconceptions that make the introduction of the religion a little difficult (although we do NOT have an official religion).

    But, as always, I don’t take their word right away! I decided to reaserch about its concepts and traditions, and I found out that this is not what I’ve been told.

    I made many muslim friends, and they’re one of the most polite people that I’ve ever known in my WHOLE LIFE! They’re not so cold and gross like people from places considered to be “educated”.

    Besided that, in order for me to understand it better, they sent me some books about the religion! From Saudi Arabia!

    Does this sound like a terrorist act for you? Don’t think so…

  2. Maryam Amirebrahimi says:

    JAZAK ALLAHU KHAYRAN FOR THIS POST. Racism in the Muslim community angers, frustrates, disappoints and baffles me. Thank you for addressing some issues related to it.

  3. Aseey/Nigeria says:

    The issue of refering to us as terrorist is among many steps by materialistic individuals to deny humanity the justice that lslam champion to all races.
    This article did justice to the topic in discussion. May Allah(swt) help the Ummah in this time of a great trial. Jazakallah kheiran.

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

More in Community, Reflections (57 of 408 articles)